Page 70 of Never Have I Ever


Font Size:

I want the world to remember desire. Urgency. A body pushed against a door because waiting even ten more steps would break you.

Maybe that’s all this is—an entire world starving and pretending it isn’t hungry. Needs unmet. Impulses denied. A pressure cooker of restraint waiting for someone to take the lid off.

I’m playing a game I perfected a long time ago. Whether you meant to join or not doesn’t matter—you’re already in. And games like mine? They have winners and losers. Losers . . . die.

The night before last, the island spoke again. A low vibration under the soil, through the salt air, sliding beneath my skin—a hum older than anyone alive, older than Catalina herself. It told me what to do next. It demanded motion.

I saw her walking alone, the moon turning her hair into a gold ribbon brushing against the night. Following her had been effortless. Natural. When she finally sensed me behind her, she startled—but then she smiled. Soft. Almost fond.

“You again,” she said.

We walked together, my steps guiding hers, up the hill toward the Chimes Tower. My pulse was steady. No nausea. No trembling. No hesitation. Everything inside me aligned—smooth as breath. It felt . . . right.

She’d been ordinary before my hands found her. But afterwards—after her final exhale—she was exquisite. Suspended from the tower, her hair swaying in the breeze, blood trailing down her pale skin, a single red brushstroke. And the bells . . . they rang because I wanted them to.

Avalon needed to hear them.

They don’t know my name, but they live inside my world. After the first death, they were uneasy. After this one? Let’s see how safety feels now. Let’s see how loudly fear echoes between their sweet little houses.

I drink with them. I laugh with them. They have no idea. Fools always make the king laugh.

Do you love how she was found? I think it’s quite poetic. Who am I? Do you know? Do you really think I’m ready to tell you? That would ruin the game, and we’re only just warming up.

When they pulled Heidi’s body down, the sun broke across her like she was carved from marble. A masterpiece. I hope thecameras captured every angle. Tonight, I’ll write her name in the sand and watch the tide erase it. Every artist signs their work.

Some will call me a monster—evil, insane.

But the truth is simpler.

There is beauty in release. Mercy in the taking.

Everyone has an angel and a devil whispering in their ears. Most people choose one. I listen to both.

And I like what they have to say. They’ve started whispering in someone else’s ear, too.

Chapter Seventeen

Things we Swallow

The plaza smelled like smoke, cumin, and onions—comfort scents that almost managed to smother the island’s unease. Every year, the Avalon Chili Cook-Off drew the whole island—families, shop owners, retirees, thrill-seekers, and gossipers pretending to be food critics. Booths lined the square, decorated with banners and pun-filled names that made everyone grin despite themselves.

Bean There

Burned That

Chili Con Carnage

Mary’s Inferno

The Heat Is On

Crack Of Dawn

Dawn of the Dead

Usually, laughter came easily during the cook-off. Today, it came fast but ended faster. People glanced over their shouldersbefore speaking. The island’s usual warmth had curled inward, watching itself.

Harmony, Cass, and Zach moved through the rows with paper cups and sampling spoons. They smiled and chatted, though nothing felt natural. It had only been days since Heidi was found hanging from the Chimes Tower. The absence felt cleaner than Harmony had expected.