Aria held a hand out to him, and he crossed the room, ready to join in on our fun. She pulled him in close and whispered into his ear, glancing at me as she filled our third alpha in with her dirty ideas. Matteo’s dark eyes heated as he listened to her words, and after she finally finished, he turned to me with a look that was practically feral. “That definitely needs to happen. It’s been too long since we’ve been together like this.”
It looked like I wasn’t the only one amongst the three of us who had been missing each other’s company over the past few weeks.
“I love having Tibby here,” Aria admitted, her expression turning a bit serious. “But sometimes it feels like everything is compartmentalized. You and Cobb. Tibby, Matteo, and I. Tibby and you. You, Matteo, and I.”
Matteo nodded, brushing a stray brunette curl over Aria’s shoulder, before looking at me again. His expression had fallen at Aria’s words, “It doesn’t feel like how a pack should feel. It should feel like a family, not whatever this is.”
Their words cooled my need for a minute as I really took a mental step backwards, and thought about what they were saying. From the beginning, both Aria and Matteo had been firm on their interest in Tibby, not only that, they’d been honest with her and themselves. I had been so wrapped up in staying the person that had protected her as a child, that I forgot that she wasn’t that child anymore—hell she wasn’t even Tabitha anymore. She’d made that very clear yesterday when she’d cried in my arms.
I guess it was time for me to finally be honest with my packmates, who had stood with me through my gunshot wound and the subsequent months of the physical and mental therapies that had occurred afterward. They’d nursed me through a broken heart, and I owed it to them to be completely honest.
“I think I’m scared,” I finally admitted. “What if I let my guard down and someone gets hurt? I don’t think I'd ever be able to recover from that.”
Aria hooked her legs around my waist and pulled me in close, sliding her panties out of the way and notching the head of my cock at her entrance. “Theo, I don’t think you understand.”
She applied pressure with her legs and practically pulled me inside of her, and we both gasped together in unison. Matteo heaved himself up onto the counter so that he could rest his chin on her shoulder as he watched my cock slide all the way home, and bottom out inside of her with just my knot hanging out. Aria held me still with her legs around my hips like a vice grip and used her hands to force me to look her in the eyes.
“We are stronger together as a united front against whatever gets thrown at us. Whether that be psycho murderers, or broken hearts. That is what the three of us have always done, except now we have two new people to think about. Cobb and Tibby would be wonderful additions to our little family, and it would almost be criminal to reject that out of fear of whatcouldhappen, don’t you agree?”
Her amber eyes were soft and intimate as we all huddled together in the living room while the two people in question slept peacefully upstairs.
Instead of answering her out loud, I drew my hips back until just the head of my cock rested inside of her pussy. I made sure that she was watching my face as I jerked my hips forward and slammed home with an aggression that only she could take. Alphas could be as aggressive as they wanted with other alphas, it was in our physiology to be able to endure rough treatment. A vestigial trait from when we used to have to fight each other for dominance, like animals in the stone ages. Now, it just meant that even if I slammed my hips into Aria’s, she wouldn’t break. Aria began to moan, and I was worried that she would wake up the people upstairs with all of the noise that she was making.
“Ria, you can’t moan like that. You’ll wake everyone up.” I chastised and lifted her off of the counter, walking the both of us into the dining room before sitting down in one of the chairs at the table. Her legs were draped on either side of my thighs as she continued to buck against me, breathy moans still tearing their way out of her throat as her insides writhed and rippled around my cock.
I turned to Matteo, who was hovering nearby with his hand firmly around his cock. His dark eyes watched us closely as he slowly pumped his hand up and down.
“Matteo, go ahead and keep Aria’s mouth busy for me so that we don’t wake our sleeping beta and omega,” I ordered and Matteo was only too happy to comply. He moved so that he was standing next to where I was bouncing Aria up and down on my cock and presented himself to her.
“What,” Aria began, a moan interrupting her next words as the angle that I was entering changed and ran along a new, more sensitive spot. “Do you say, oh shit, Theo slow down for a sec.”
I ignored her request, instead choosing to slam her down harder onto my lap and her pussy seized and spasmed around me as she came with a little scream that was cut off when Matteo shoved his cock into her open mouth.
Aria breathed heavily through her nose as the aftershocks of her first orgasm shuddered through her, and she glared balefully up at the alpha who’d filled her mouth, and I knew that she wouldn’t begin to lick until she got what she wanted.
“Matteo.” My voice came out in an order that bordered on a bark, “what do you say to Ria?”
Matteo grinned, his breathing already coming out in excited little huffs, “please, Mistress Ria.”
Satisfied by his obedience, I watched as her tongue slid around his cock, and she took him more fully into her throat, the tendons in her neck constricting as he thrust forward deeply with a gasp.
This was the dynamic between the three of us. Aria and I battled for dominance, sometimes one of us won and sometimes the other did. Matteo, however, relished being told what to do. By either of us, though Aria definitely had the dominatrix persona down pat. Even now I watched her lip lift, I could see one of her canine teeth scraping gently along the side of Matteo’s cock as he pumped into her mouth. Matteo’s dark eyes squeezed shut, and he pressed his fist to his mouth to keep from moaning out loud himself.
Not wanting Aria to forget that I existed, I jerked my hips upwards into her sensitive cunt and bumped up against her cervix and the walls of her pussy shuddered around me violently. Aria gasped around Matteo’s cock as I resumed moving, my hands digging so hard into her hips that I was sure that they would leave bruises for her to take with her when she went to work later.
A tight, shuddering, feeling began to come through my body in crashing waves, and I knew that I wasn’t going to last much longer. Judging by the muffled moans coming from Matteo and Aria, neither of them would last long either.
I refused to let Aria off with only one orgasm, my left hand snaked around to her backside, my fingers sliding down her spine and into the cleft of her ass cheeks as she rocked against me. I quickly found the tight rosebud of flesh there, and began to prod at it with my pointer finger.
Aria voiced a muffled complaint when she realized what I was doing, and I couldn’t help the grin. “Aria, didn’t anyone ever tell you not to talk with your mouth full?”
Her amber eyes promised that she would get my back for this, and I slid my finger fully into her ass as my other hand, still gripping her hip, pushed her fully down onto my cock. I couldn’t knot Aria, her insides were too narrow and tight, a biological difference that would allow her to constrict around the cock of a male omega. A knot would never be a source of pleasure for her, but that didn’t stop her from snaking a free hand down underneath her undulating hips to give the ring of the flesh a firm squeeze.
“Shit,” I muttered and buried my face into the valley of her breasts, and Tibby’s strawberries and cream scent filled my nostrils as I came with a muffled shout. My orgasm triggered both Matteo and Aria’s, and I could hear Matteo’s gasp as he emptied himself down Aria’s throat with a grunt muffled around his fist. Aria’s insides twisted around my cock, which was currently bathing her insides with my warm cum as she came for a second time. Her legs and toes stiffened as she shuddered around me.
Matteo withdrew first and Aria gasped as he slid out of her throat, pulling up one of the other chairs next to us and collapsing into it.
We stayed like that for a few minutes, trying to catch our breaths because, let’s face it, we weren’t as young as we used to be.
