He nodded. She let out her breath and he realized she wasfrustrated. “They could have said anything in the world aboutyou, couldn’t they? That bastard could have called you whatever he liked, could have tried to lay claim to all that is yours, and you would have done nothing.”
Ewan shrugged and signed, “You matter.”
She caught her breath, horror replacing her frustration. “You matter!” she signed, her hands flying wildly as she sloppily spelled out those pointed words.
“Do either of you want to tell the rest of us what you’re saying?” Baldwin asked, leaning in a bit closer.
Color darkened Charlotte’s cheeks, but she snapped, “No!” Then she continued signing to Ewan. “You matter, Ewan. To me, to all the people in this house, to your tenants, to your friends. Why does what your father or your brothers or your mother say mean more to you than what all of us think? If I matter so much, then why can’t my love for you have as much weight as your father’s hate?”
He flinched at the directness of her question. She seemed to recognize it too, in that moment. Some of the anger left her eyes, replaced with guilt. “I’m sorry,” she whispered, turning her face.
“Neither one of you wants to say what you’re discussing?” Aunt Mary said, her gaze settling on Ewan with gentleness.
Charlotte stared at the foyer floor, her shoulders shaking. “I-I am out of sorts. I should…I should go elsewhere.” She lifted her gaze to him. “I’m sorry,” she repeated, softer, her teary gaze holding his for a beat before she turned on her heel and fled the foyer.
Leaving Ewan to stare after her, uncertain how to proceed. Luckily, he didn’t have to decide. The Duchess of Sheffield looked at the group at large, but her gaze lingered on him. Like she understood something that hadn’t been entirely clear to her before.
“I’ll go speak to her,” she said with a small smile for him. She patted Baldwin’s arm and then followed where Charlotte had gone.
Everyone left behind in the foyer seemed to be waiting for him to respond in some way. He dug into his pocket and found his notebook. He scribbled, “I need a moment. Excuse me.”
He handed the note to his cousin and left the room, heading for his study. Hoping he could clear his mind. Knowing it might not be possible.
“How long have you loved him?”
Charlotte caught her breath and spun to watch her mother enter her chamber. The Duchess of Sheffield closed the door behind her and leaned back, observing her daughter with a knowing stare.
“Always,” Charlotte admitted with a sigh that felt like it came from the depths of her soul. “From the first moment I saw him. Childish love. But it turned into something much deeper.”
Her mother’s brow wrinkled. “Then why did you marry Portsmith, Charlotte?”
Charlotte bent her head. It sounded like such a simple question and it wasn’t. But she had no energy to try to hide the truth anymore.
“I went to Ewan before my marriage and I tried to confess my heart to him. But what you saw down there, what those people have done to him, said to him, how they’ve treated him…it holds so much weight. The past keeps him from taking our future. He refused me all those years ago.”
The duchess took a deep breath and moved toward her. “I’m sorry. It must have hurt you deeply.”
Charlotte turned and stared out the window to the sea. On this day, she saw it, rolling and crashing against the cliffs. Beautiful and treacherous, rather like the feelings that still swelled inside of her.
“It broke my heart. But I tried to make the best of it. I knew what was expected of me. I hoped I could make it work with Portsmith. But married or not, Ewan was all I loved. All I wanted. So here I was, coming to his home with my mourning coming to an end. I’d heard all about these love stories blossoming for our friends, I’d seen the power of Simon and Meg’s connection up close. It made me long for Ewan all the more. I was determined to try again. I would do…Ihavedone everything in my power to try to make him see that wecouldhave a future.”
The duchess’s eyes went wide and her cheeks brightened. “I see.”
“But he still insists that what those fools, those cruel, empty fools, say is important. He still sees himself as damaged. And he’s still afraid that the damage will destroy our happiness in the end. So I think he will turn away from me once more.” The tears she had been fighting won out and began to slide down her cheeks. “And this time he will be lost to me forever.”
“Oh, darling,” her mother said, stepping to her and folding her into her arms. Charlotte clung to her for a moment. “If it helps, I think he does love you in return.”
Charlotte shut her eyes. Ewan loved her. That did not come as a surprise, of course. Some part of her knew that, perhaps had known that as long as she’d known her own heart. “And yet he pushes me away at every turn,” she whispered.
“Have you told him this is the last chance you will be able to offer?” her mother asked, drawing back to look at Charlotte closely. “Have you made that entirely clear?”
“I’ve asked him to make a decision,” Charlotte said. “And told him that when I return to London, I will go back to the marriage mart.”
Her mother sighed. “That should be enough, but sometimes men need a little extra…push.”
Charlotte considered that a moment. “Perhaps you are right. I bought him a gift. The shopkeep in town was supposed to have it delivered here today, but instead he’s asked me to come retrieve it myself.”
The duchess’s expression brightened. “I think that’s a fine idea, actually. You and I could go to town to retrieve this item. Give yourself some space and give Ewan space, too. Let him speak to his family and to your brother. Let him have a moment to consider what is before him and what he could lose.”
