Page 17 of Behind Their Eyes


Font Size:

But her only flaw was that she trusted too easily.

I was twenty at the time and thought it could never happen to me or someone I cared about.

But one night it happened, and I wasn’t there.

I was working a part-time construction job while in school. I wanted my mom to not have to be concerned with what food options I had and if I needed anything extra while going to class.

When my phone rang, I expected to answer and for her to complain that I didn’t make it back in time for our late night pizza run and our second time of re-watching The Vampire Diaries. Instead, I had an officer on the other end of the line asking me if I was her next of kin.

That is the specific detail my brain replayed on a continuous punishment loop. It was her I expected to answer the phone.

Not the police who asked me to come to the scene.

Her body was found by a room-mate she shared the dorm with.

The officer who spoke to me kept using small words to explain the entire situation to me as if I were a child and knew nothing of the dangers in the world.

He spoke gently and carefully, like it would soften what had happened. I remember staring at hismouth, watching syllables move while my brain refused to translate them into anything real.

Blunt force trauma. Sexual assault. Time of death.

I never asked for anymore details. My imagination was already too willing.

They let me see her once before the funeral and I wish they hadn’t.

I wanted to remember her as the person who snorted through laughter. The one whose cheeks blushed when she caught me staring at her in class. The one I saw my entire life with.

After the service, the world expected me to move on. My mother cried quietly and tried not to look at me like I was something fragile she might break by accident.

But grief didn’t make me reckless. It made me methodical. Angry in a way that required structure. I started asking questions no one wanted to answer. Names. Faces. Patterns. Who drank where. Who bragged about what.

That was how I fell into the rabbit hole of the Italian Mafia.

Through obsession. Through her.

I didn’t join because I wanted some type of power. I only joined because they knew things. Because information traveled faster in those type of circles than it ever did through police files. I told myself I’d get what I needed and leave and that would change everything for me. I was only there to find the man who had ruined herlife and mine.

I found him, eventually, but it didn’t satisfy me like I thought it would. Instead, the anger grew inside my own head. It raged because I had no one else to blame. The problem was gone, I took care of it.

At least, I thought I had.

But I was still here, and I still felt everything like it was yesterday.

It didn’t bring her back to me. It didn’t silence the wrath in my head. It didn’t make the nights easier without her. I kept expecting something like closure to drop from the sky and knock my ass out.

Nothing ever did.

So I stayed with the bad guys.

Fury is easier to live with when you give it somewhere to acclimate. The mob gave mine direction. I learned how to channel my rage into precision.

And the money definitely helped. Or it was a decent enough distraction.

But women were different. They always had been after her.

Well, women, children and anyone smart enough to convince me that they were innocent.

I couldn’t put my hands on them without memories flashing in uninvited.