“What about us?” Pete asks, leaning toward me.
“Why won’t you have sex with me?” I finally blurt out, my eyes bouncing between their stunned expressions.
When nobody answers, I swallow nervously before asking, “Am I doing something wrong? Do you notwantto sleep with me?”
Jagger stands and lifts me, settling back on the bed with me in his lap as we face the others.
“Baby, of course, we want to have sex with you,” Dex tells me as he reaches forward to squeeze my hand in reassurance.
“It’s pretty much all I think about,” Pete admits, making me huff out a laugh.
“Really?”
“Fuck yeah,” he says, a grin returning to his sexy mouth.
“We were waiting until you’re ready.”
“I’ve been ready for a while. I just wasn’t sure how to tell you,” I admit as each of them touches me somewhere, a foot, my leg, my hand.
“Thank you for telling us now,” Sly says with a nod. “But since this is your first time, we need to figure out how to do this.”
“What do you mean?”
“Well, who is going first?”
I blink, my brain short-circuiting at the thought. I hadn’t even considered that, and the idea of having to choose makes me grow a little anxious.
“I think it should be me,” Dex says, puffing out his chest. “I was the first to claim her as my girlfriend.”
“Fuck no, you’ll tear her open with your monster cock,” Pete says in alarm, his concern worrying me, before his tone turns serious. “It should obviously be me.”
“How did you come to that conclusion?” Sly asks in exasperation.
“I’m long and strong.” He looks at me and winks before looking back at the others. “You guys are too thick. I’ll do less damage, but my womb raider will be sure to show her a good time.”
Did he just call his dick a womb raider?My eyes widen, unsure if I’m horrified or intrigued.
“Please,” Dex says with a roll of his eyes. “You’ll be messy and are likely to finish before she’s even had a chance to orgasm once.”
I lift my hands to cover my red cheeks in embarrassment.
“You know the second you get inside her, you’ll lose your load,” Pete fires back.
“I have the most control, it should be me,” Sly says with a sigh, like it’s so obvious.
Jagger starts signing around my body, making it a little hard to translate, but luckily, Pete reads it aloud.
“You are too dominating to be her first. You might not realize if you push her too far.”
Sly’s eyes turn angry as he sets them on Jagger. “I would never push her past her hard limits. She’d do best with me. She needs a firm hand to guideher for the first time.”
“That’s bullshit,” Pete says at the same time Dex shakes his head, also disagreeing.
Is this really happening right now? Are they actually arguing over who is going to have sex with me first? Somehow, I hadn’t expected this. Of all the outcomes I anticipated, having them debate who did the deed was not one I had considered.
“It’s not. Wren needs control. She needs to know what to do and how to do it,” Sly says, staring down the others.
Suddenly, the door bangs open, and I jump into Jagger’s lap, only calming when I see it’s Elias.
