As if he'd sensed her thoughts, Jake's hands—which had been running over her backside, caressing the curves of her bottom and making her lower body tingle enthusiastically—slowed and his right hand moved toward the crease between her cheeks and the thick plug of rubber filling her there.
Evelyn whimpered around Wilson's cock as Jake began to play with the stopper in her bottom.
On the second day of her marriage they'd started plugging her, beginning with a very small one to train her bottom for them. She hadn't put up much protest, still worried at the time that they'd turn her out, and had found she didn't hate the sensation. Then they'd taught her how to suck their cocks. That had given her poor pussy time to recover, which was just as well.
No matter how tired they were when they finished up their work on the ranch, it was rare that both of them were too tired to claim marital rights. And once one of them started up, the other one usually ended up joining in, tired or not.
Last week Jake had put his cock in her bottom for the first time. They'd been working their way through larger and larger rubber dilators, getting her bottom used to being stretched, until Jake could have her that way while Wilson used her mouth. It had been so strange... painful and uncomfortable and yet hotly pleasurable at the same time. Evelyn had discovered she quite liked being wicked. Two days later, after her bottom had had some time to recover, they'd repeated the position but with Wilson claiming his turn in her tight hole while she moaned around Jake's cock.
They'd told her that this week they'd be taking her at the same time—not with one in her mouth and the other tending to her lower half, but both of them together, one in her pussy and one in her ass.
"What do you reckon, Wilson?" Jake asked casually, twisting the dilator and beginning to pump it a little, fucking her with it. Her hole tried to clench, but he'd lubed the rubber stopper well enough that her muscles couldn't grip it, and the attempt only increased the pleasurable friction. "Think our beautiful wife is ready to take both of us at the same time?"
A thrill went through Evelyn's breast, making her nipples tingle even though fear flickered as well, and she moaned, unsure of whether she was excited or frightened by the prospect.
Smiling, Wilson looked down at her. His fingers were threaded through her hair, holding her head in place while he pumped his cock in and out of her mouth.
"I think so. What do you think, sweetheart? Are you ready to take one of us in your hot little pussy and the other in your sweet ass?"
She whimpered. Shuddered as Jake pumped the dilator more enthusiastically. She might be frightened, but the growing ache in her pussy said she was definitely ready.
Wilson's cock slid out from between her lips, leaving them swollen from use, and he chuckled as he lay back on their large bed, pulling her atop them. His eyes softened as he looked up at her, tender and full of love, heat, and desire.
"Climb on, love, Jake and I want to claim you completely."
She couldn't help but giggle, even as his cock found the entrance to her soaked pussy, pressing in and filling her so delightfully.
"As if I haven't already been claimed in every hole you two could find," she teased.
They'd even created some she'd never imagined, like when Wilson had poured warm oil between her breasts and wrapped the soft flesh around his cock, thrusting through the mounds of flesh as if it was her pussy.
Jake's hands slid down her back as she sank down onto Wilson's cock, caressing and massaging. She moaned. This wasn't the first time she'd had a dilator in her bottom and a cock in her pussy, and she loved how full it felt, as if every single nerve ending in her body was fully charged with sensation.
She'd become a brazen thing in the security of their home and marriage, happy and in love, and they loved her for it.
One husband's hands helped lift her on the other's cock, making it easier for her rise and fall, to ride him like she would a horse. Her thighs, while still supple, now had some muscle from actual horseback riding she'd done and she had become an accomplished rider of her husbands as well.
Groaning, Wilson's own hips lifted, thrusting up into her body as he cupped her breasts, squeezing the soft mounds roughly, his thumbs sweeping over her swollen nipples. Evelyn moaned with him as she felt Jake began to slide the dilator from her ass, leaving her empty and aching even as Wilson filled her pussy over and over again.
Hands on her hips slowed her rhythm and the blunt head of Jake's cock pressed against her anus. Evelyn gasped.
Her husband wasn't much thicker than the dilator, but that wasn't how it felt now that his cock was pushing into her asshole, competing for room with Wilson's cock already stuffing her pussy full. The tight muscle of her sphincter burned as Jake pushed in, and she whined high in the back of her throat at the sensation.
"Oh... oh... "
Arching between the two hard bodies of her husbands, Evelyn clawed at Wilson's shoulders as Jake's cock slid in besidehis. She understood now why they'd been so careful about slowly prepping her for this moment.
She was fuller than she'd ever been before. Certainly fuller than the dilator had ever made her.
There were two cocks inside of her, pulsing and throbbing on their own, the men's tiniest movements stimulating her sensitive openings. As Jake's body came to rest atop hers, his cock fully buried inside her ass, she could feel the heat of his groin, the curls of his body hair tickling her anus.
She could barely breathe, she was stuffed so full of her husbands.
Then they began to move, and the difference in sensation between two cocks versus a cock and a dilator immediately became clear.
Two hot, hard, throbbing cocks were now alternating movements, fucking her between them, the weight of two men pressing in on her from either side, and it was so much hotter, so much wetter, so much more pleasurable than the dilator had been.
Almost overwhelmingly so.
