The thrusting had become increasingly erratic, both of them picking up pace and not entirely evenly, until I felt Mitch's hard thrust into my ass. He groaned, holding himself completely still, and I could feel every pulse of his cock as he filled up my backside with hot cream. The sudden stillness in my ass sent Ethan into overdrive, making me clench tightly around both of them, milking Mitch as Ethan groaned and tensed beneath me.
I sobbed into Ethan's chest as I felt him begin to come inside me. My pussy was hot and tingly, as if someone was running an electric current through it. The pulses of pleasure didn't subside until both men had emptied themselves into my body, and only then was I able to relax between them.
Relax... hell, I collapsed. Crying again.
"Allie, are you okay?"
"Talk to us, sweetheart."
"We didn't hurt you, did we?"
The concerned voices helped to anchor me and I heaved, taking in a deep, shuddering breath as I felt them carefully dislodge from my body. "I'm good. I'm fine... That was just... more than I expected.... oh fuck..."
Mitch chuckled as Ethan's arms tightened around me, his hand stroking my hair.
"Stay put, I'm going to get something to clean you up," Mitch said, patting my bottom affectionately.
If my legs didn't feel so weak I might have kicked him. I rolled my eyes. Like I'd thought, Mitch was acting like having sex was no big deal.
It was really Ethan's reaction I was more worried about. He'd become a lot more unpredictable today.
I heard the door to the office close and realized that the rolling sounds of thunder had stopped. Although we probably still had some time before any of the other poolrats showed up.
With my head resting on Ethan's chest and his fingers making soothing little circles on my back, I found that I really didn't want to move. Especially since the lower half of my body felt like it had gone on vacation. I didn't want to look at him either, that might ruin the moment.
Even though Mitch hadn't changed his demeanor toward me, I really hoped that Ethan would. If he was mean to me now or had totally lost respect for me then I would deal with it, but I couldn't help remembering that little comment Mitch had made about Ethan's feelings for me. I had no idea whether or not to take that seriously, but a little kernel of hope had sprung up inside me.
"So... what are you doing tonight?"
I was so entranced by the rumbling vibrations his chest made when he spoke that it took me a moment to sort out what he'd actually said.
"Um... hanging out at the pool till it closes and then going home. The usual." At least I prayed that was what I'd be doing. If he was mean to me now, I might run. After putting some clothes on, of course.
I could feel him toying with the ends of my hair, wrapping it around his fingers. Dammit, if I had to run that might hurt.
"I was hoping maybe you'd go to dinner with me after I get off work."
"Really?" I couldn't keep the shock out of my voice and I pushed up on my hands so that I could see his face. I needed to be able to see his expression and judge his sincerity.
The look he was giving me was decidedly grumpy. Handsome, hot as hell, but definitely grumpy.
"Well yeah... didn't you hear Mitch say that I'd always had a crush on you?"
He asked the question fiercely, but he was blushing too. I stared, more than a little fascinated.
Then I shook myself, remembering that I was naked on top of him. Great, now we were both blushing.
I let out a little huff of air. "Yes, butyoudidn't say anything."
"Well, I am now. Will you go out to dinner with me?"
"You don't care that I just had sex with you and your best friend?"
Now it was Ethan's turn to be a little huffy. "Honestly? It's not my ideal scenario and I'm not sure I'd ever want to repeat it again... it was like combining heaven and hell. Heaven because I was fulfilling my fantasy of being with you, and hell because your fantasy involved more than just me."
I smiled, feeling a little shy, which was absurd, given the circumstances.
"If it helps, I think my curiosity has been appeased. That was amazing, but not something I'd want to do on a regular basis. If ever again."
