“We’ll carry you out if you need.” West teased her nipple, pinching it gently. “Fuck, you’ll never have to walk again if you don’t want to.”
I looked up at her and saw that her eyes had widened and she was staring at West with her lip caught between her teeth. His words banged around my head. If he’d said something like that to anyone else I would’ve laughed but it felt different with Cassidy. West didn’t look like he was joking. A wave of nerves hit me. Everything felt real, almost too real.
“We won’t hurt you.” Hayes sucked on her earlobe and did something with his fingers that made her face go blank. “If it takes all night and you want to ride my face for hours, I’ll make fucking sure you’re ready for us before we fuck you.”
Cassidy’s hand pumped up and down my dick faster as her breathing sped up. “Oh, god. Right there, Hayes. Feels so good.”
He smirked at me over her shoulder and I felt my fears slide away. Whatever happened happened. I closed my mouth over her left nipple and sucked. Her hand fisted in my hair and she letout a strangled cry. Maybe it should’ve been strange when I felt West beside me, sucking her other nipple, but it didn’t phase me. We were all focused on making Cassidy feel good. That was what mattered.
I heard West grunt beside me and knew where her hand had gone when she pulled it from my hair. She stroked her hand up and down my dick with the perfect pressure to make me lose my mind. I pushed her panties down and maneuvered my hand around Hayes’. He was teasing her clit so I found her core and played with her. I dipped my fingertip inside and swirled it around over and over again. Her moans grew more feverish as her hips rocked between us.
I lifted my head after giving her nipple one last tug and saw that Hayes had her head turned back so he could kiss her. Seeing it was oddly erotic. We all looked so much alike with our eyes closed that it was almost like I was watching myself with her. She was stretched out, doing her best to touch all of us at the same time. I pushed my finger deeper and inhaled roughly at the feeling of her body clamping down on my finger. My vision blurred slightly when West pushed a finger in next to mine. She was tight and so fucking wet.
“On the bed. Jesus.” Hayes pushed her to the bed and dragged her to the middle of it. “Look at how pretty you are, Cassidy.”
West pushed Hayes out of the way with an uncharacteristically light grin and settled between Cassidy’s thighs. “Can I eat this pussy, sweetheart?”
She reached up and plucked his cowboy hat off his head and dropped it on hers. “Please, Cowboy.”
I climbed on the other side of the bed and touched her everywhere I could. I stroked her silky skin and paid special attention to her navel, then her nipples. Hayes kissed her until her moans ran into one another, one growing before the one before could finish..
West devoured her. Every sound he let out made it clear just how much he was loving her pussy. She twisted and arched and cried out his name with a broken voice. West lifted his head and looked up at her with his face shiny from her juices. “So fucking beautiful, Cassidy. So delicious.”
She grabbed his hair and pushed his head back between her thighs. He went with a low laugh. When she was satisfied that he wasn’t going to move she reached out and grabbed my hips. Her eyes were wild as they focused on mine. “Let me taste you. Both of you.”
Hayes shoved his underwear off and I swore when it took me a second too long. Hayes had her head turned in his direction and was watching her stretch her lips wide to take his dick into her mouth. I watched with my breath caught in my lungs. Seeing the woman I’d become instantly obsessed with suck my brother’s dick was strange at first but when she popped her mouth free and turned her head to do the same to mine, I forgot any hesitations that might’ve come rushing back. Her mouth was violently hot and tight, a blitz of intense pleasure and then gone just as fast.
West sat back on his haunches and pumped two fingers in and out of Cassidy while watching her twist from side to side to take Hayes deep in her perfect mouth and then come back to me. “Perfect. You were made for us, weren’t you, sweetheart? This delicious pussy is dripping wet. You want to be ours, don’t you?”
She moaned around my cock and I saw stars. When West pressed his thumb over her clit we all watched as her body flushed. Hayes and I both plucked at her nipples, hungry to see her come for us.
“That’s it, Cassidy. So fucking sexy.” Hayes grunted when she took his dick deep again. “That’s enough, baby. I’m not coming before you. You come first. Always.”
“First and multiple times before we come. Stretch out and let us worship you, sweetheart.” West bared his teeth when she started rocking her hips, chasing her pleasure. “Yeah, Cassidy, take what you need. Use us to get off.”
“Where the fuck did you come from? You’re fucking perfect. Stay with us. I want to spend the night making your beautiful body shake and come. Let us spoil you, Cassidy.” I felt drunk and had no control over the words coming out of my mouth. I justwanted. I wanted so badly it hurt. “So fucking beautiful, so goddamnright.”
Cassidy froze between us, her eyes open and fixated on mine. She was so close to coming that I could see the release hovering on the edge of her sanity.
Then something shifted. Her breath hitched. Her eyes went glassy—not with pleasure anymore, but with something raw and terrified.
"I have to go." Her voice cracked. "I'm so sorry. I can't—I can't do this."
She scrambled off the bed before any of us could react, grabbing her clothes and clutching them to her chest like armor. Her hands were shaking.
"Cassidy, wait—" West started.
She paused at the door. For one brutal second, she looked back at us. And I saw it. The longing. The want. Written all over her face.
Then she was gone and the three of us sat in stunned silence.
"What the hell just happened?" Hayes ran a hand through his hair.
I stared at the door, my chest tight, voice strained. "She felt it too. That's why she ran."
6
***Cass***
