She gripped the bed and dropped her head forward. “N-no.”
“You want us to pop that cherry for you, sweetheart?” I moved back down to her shoulder and nipped her. “You want to let me lick and finger your sweet little asshole before I fuck it?”
She cried out my name and her arms buckled. With her face turned to the side so she didn’t suffocate she nodded. Her ass was in the air already and I watched as goosebumps broke out across her bare back. Her shorts and panties were still hanging on so I yanked them down her thighs and then she was bare for us. Chills ran up and down my spine as I stepped back to see her.
West and Cash were already ready to go again and I could feel them next to me, each breathing hard at the sight Cassidy made in front of us. With her knees spread wide on the bed she was on display in the sexiest way. Her pink cunt was shiny with her juices, her lower lips puffy and inviting.
“Reach back and hold yourself open for us, sweetheart.” I didn’t recognize my voice or half the shit coming out of my mouth but seeing her on her knees, asking for what she wanted had done something to me. What we were doing was fucking filthy but I’d never been harder.
Cassidy whimpered and I watched the half of her face I could see turn red but her hands came up and she gripped her tight ass cheeks to pull herself open. Seeing her lips open and expose that tight hole I’d just had my fingers in and the other one I was about to get my fingers in made my balls tighten and my dick jump against my jeans.
“Goddamn…” West moved forward and dipped his finger in her wetness and then brought it to his mouth to taste. “You’ve got the prettiest pussy I’ve ever seen. And this asshole… It’s going to make a nice home for my cock, isn’t it?”
“Yes!” Cassidy moaned his name when he coated his finger with her juices and then teased her ass. He dipped the tip of his finger into her and then pushed two fingers into her sex. Her fingers tightened and I could see her blunt nails were digging into her pale flesh. “Please!”
I’d waited patiently enough so I pushed West aside and dropped to my knees behind her. I gripped her ass and pushed her hands away. “You need to be as wet as you can be to take us, baby. I’m not coming up for air until you give me another few orgasms. You need West or Cash to come up there and give you something to fill your mouth?”
I was too busy burying my face in her pussy to see them but I felt my brothers struggling to see who was going to get to her first. I closed my mouth over her clit and circled it with my tongue to ease her into what I really wanted. I could see her body tighten and then relax again when I gently stroked her. Then I sucked hard and held her steady as she let out a muffled scream and almost bucked off the bed.
I gripped her ass harder and then gave her a break by taking long, wide licks of her from clit to asshole. She was dripping wet, coating the insides of her thighs, but I still lifted my mouth from her so I could spit on her asshole. I didn’t miss the way her bodyshivered from it. I rubbed her asshole, dipping my thumb inside, just the tip, and went back to licking her.
At her other end I could hear her gagging and knew she was taking a cock down her throat. My dick leaked as I straightened my tongue and fucked her with it. I kept my thumb against her ass, pressing more and more firmly until she relaxed enough for it to slide inside the tight ring of muscle. The sound of her panting was loud and I glanced up to see she had her head tossed back, staring at the ceiling while Cash stroked his dick in front of her. One touch of my tongue against her clit made her back arch and a sound of pleasure come out of her mouth unlike anything I’d ever heard before.
I shifted and pressed my dick against the side of the bed in hopes of easing the pain. I needed to fuck her but I wasn’t done tasting her. Cash pulled her mouth back to his dick and I restarted the whole game with her cunt. I worked my thumb deeper and then adjusted so I had two fingers pushing inside instead. Her asshole clenched down on my fingers but I stroked her lower back while gently lapping at her clit, letting her relax again before I moved them.
Drinking down two more orgasms, I didn’t stop until she was a writhing, sweaty mess with her hair sticking to her forehead and three of my fingers fucking her ass like I had her pussy. West had shifted into Cash’s place and he had her head held down on his cock with a wild look on his face.
“I’m in her fucking throat. Jesus!” He yanked her head up and I listened to the sounds of her heavy breathing and moaning all mixed together. She was ready.
I stood up, yanked my jeans down, and was about to go into her bareback again but when she felt my bare skin against hers she reached back and grabbed my leg. “Condom.”
48
***Hayes***
Iswore and reached over to grab one from West’s bedside drawer. I hadn’t worn one the first time with her. I’d never made that mistake before and it should’ve terrified me more but there I was, ready to do it again.
“Got it, baby.” I leaned over her and pressed a kiss to the center of her back. The slight taste of salt from her sweat mixing with her naturally sweet taste made me groan and lean back down for more. I traced her spine with my tongue and lined my dick up with her core.
Her pussy felt like magic around my cock as I filled her and for a second I wondered what the fuck I was doing pulling out to go anywhere else. I wanted her cherry, though. I wanted to leave my mark on her body, claim part of her that would be mine and mine alone. I was a greedy fuck when it came to her.
After soaking my cock in her wetness I lined my head up with her asshole and pushed. She tensed but I stroked her back and praised her with words I wasn’t even comprehending until sherelaxed enough for my tip to get inside. Her muscles pulsed closed on me and I had to tip my head back and think about my football stats to keep from blowing my load right away.
Cassidy slapped the bed and dropped her head to rest on West’s thigh. “Fuck. You’re too big. God, Hayes!”
I reached under her to rub her clit as Cash shifted closer to her to pepper kisses along her shoulder. “We can stop, sweetheart.”
She made a sound like an angry cat and pushed her hips back at me. More of my length slid in and my eyes rolled back in my head at the pleasure. “I’m not a quitter.”
There was something so fucking hot about hearing a competitive edge to her voice right then. I rubbed her clit harder and reached forward to grip the back of her neck. “Say stop and it ends, Cassidy.”
The look she tossed over her shoulder at me promised mutiny. “Fuck me, Hayes.”
I pushed forward and bared my teeth at her. “Fuck you? Be more specific, baby.”
Her head dropped forward again and I saw West jerk as she quickly sucked at his cock before breaking away again. “Fuck my ass, Hayes.”
“Such a dirty mouth.” Cash pulled her in his direction and ran his dick over her lips. “Open up, sweetheart. Muffle those screams with my cock.”
