He grins and steps out. I clean up the best I can. There’s a little tinge of blood on the toilet paper, but nothing major. That was it. That was my virginity gone. Such a fuss over something so minor.
My pulse races as I look at the door. I have four more firsts to get through today. Each of the guys will be different, feel different. I don’t know if everyone gets a turn or what.
I didn’t think we’d get this far honestly. But I can’t wait to find out.
CHAPTER 35
The Lit Fuse
Luke
Caden stands and heads for the bathroom. I follow him. My mind still can’t wrap around what happened. She chose Caden to be her first. Not me.
Does she only want Caden, and she’s tolerating the rest of us?
Fuck that.
Caden knocks on the bathroom door. “You okay?”
Harper opens the door with her cheeks stained pink. She nods and looks at me. Her dark eyes flash with heat. My body responds with a primal need to claim her, but I hold myself back.
“What do you need?” Caden cups her cheek, tipping her head to meet his eyes. “It’s up to you how we go from here.”
Her eyes widen, and her gaze darts back to me. Her face softens when she turns back to Caden and puts her hand over his. “I’m good. We can explore more or do something else.”
“Why don’t we put on a movie and relax for a little while?” Nico suggests.
My jaw clenches, but I can see their point. Just because I want to fuck her, doesn’t mean they don’t want to fuck her too. But she might be sore. Caden is a huge motherfucker.
I grab my boxers and my t-shirt. Before anyone else can, I stepforward and put my t-shirt on over her head and help her get her arms through. Needing to claim her in whatever way I can.
“Thank you.” She looks up at me shyly and brushes her hair behind her ear. This uncertain, shy thing she’s got going is new. I’m not sure I like it.
The others go to find their boxers, and I step into mine. She bites her lip as I put away my hard cock. Stepping into her, I feel her warmth against me and draw her into my arms. She wraps her arms around my waist and rests her head over my heart.
Can she tell how hard it pounds for her?
“We’ll go as slow as you want, princess.” I press my lips to the top of her dark hair, even as I want to rip out my own vocal cords. Every time I imagined Harper losing her virginity, I was the one taking it.
Now, Caden’s cum is the first our girl has tasted and had in her tight little cunt. Sure, I took her first orgasm, the first taste of her pussy, and the first to sleep with her, but fuck, I wanted them all.
Harper squeezes me tight and looks up at me. The others have moved to the TV and are scrolling to find something. Her dark eyes fascinate me.
“I don’t know how to do this,” she whispers. Her eyes search mine.
“Do what?” I glance over at the guys, who focus on the TV. Well, mostly focus. They glance over at Harper.
She swallows and drops her gaze to my throat. “I don’t want to be done.”
My cock throbs at what I hope she’s saying. I tip her chin to force her eyes to meet mine. “You want to play more, princess?”
Her tongue darts out to wet her lips. She nods.
The opening credits of a movie play in the background.
I can’t stop the smile that forms on my lips as I take her hand and lead her to a chair. I sit down and draw her down onto my lap, straddling me.
Sliding my hand between her legs, I stroke her pussy gently. She makes this little needy noise that makes my balls tighten and ache with need. Eli glances over at us from his chair and lifts an eyebrow at me.
