“Me too,” Colton added.
I grinned. “You guys are too cute. What do you plan on doing while I plow Eric?”
Eric made a tiny noise of surprise in his throat. His face was red.
“Dunno,” Ramsay replied good-naturedly. “I was gonna jack off, but I’ll do whatever you want me to.”
Colton nodded in agreement.
I ordered Eric to retrieve the lube. Since he was an alpha, he didn’t have the natural slick that I did, and he would need it to be penetrated with ease and comfort. Ramsay and Colton casually stripped down and waited for further instructions.
“Eric,” I said.
“Y-yes?”
“Strip down. I want to see your bare ass.”
Licking his lips, Eric shimmied out of his clothes until every inch of his skin was visible. I looked him up and down, appreciating his form. He was so stunning.
I smiled at him and said, “Come closer. I want to kiss you first.”
I loved the power dynamic of me being fully clothed and Eric’s complete nudity. His skin was warm as he pressed against my chest. We kissed, slow and sensual. It brought my cock to life and I moaned softly into his mouth. I felt Eric’s own erection strain against my clothes. Knowing he was on display for Colton and Ramsay to see made my cock throb.
As Eric pulled away, I glanced at Colton and Ramsay.
“You two undress as well,” I said. “I want all of my alphas naked.”
“Bossy,” Ramsay mumbled with a sly grin. He was already in the middle of complying, and Colton never needed to be told twice to strip down. When they were done, I took a moment to rake my eyes over all three of them and their gorgeous bodies. How did I get so lucky?
I quickly threw my shirt off and shoved my pants down to my mid-thighs. I summoned Colton with a crook of my finger, and he shuffled forward obediently. I smiled at him.
“Can you lube up my cock for me?” I asked.
Colton nodded and dumped a pool of lube into his palm, then firmly wrapped his fingers around my aching cock. I groaned at the sensation of cool liquid against my hot flesh. Colton’s hand moved deliciously up and down, perhaps stroking me a little more than necessary but I didn’t mind.
“Thanks,” I said when I was thoroughly lubed up. “Your turn, Eric. Bend over.”
His eyes widened, glinting with both lust and surprise when he realized I was going to do. He leaned forward and raised his ass, presenting himself to me. I carefully eased his hole open and poured a small stream of lube into his ass. Eric shuddered and groaned.
“Goddamn, that’s hot,” Ramsay mumbled. From the corner of my eye, I saw him stroking his cock. I thought it was cute how much he enjoyed watching me have sex with the others.
“Ready for me to stretch you?” I asked Eric, who nodded vigorously. I slipped a finger inside his dripping wet hole. The lube soaked up the friction, making it easy for me to go inside until it hit my knuckle.
His muscle twitched and opened up around my second finger as Eric let out a soft hiss of pleasure. He arched his back, leaning into my touch. I was pleased to see him so compliant. I began gently scissoring my fingers inside his ass, testing what felt good and what was uncomfortable, but Eric never had any complaints. His cock was aching and hard as it strained against his belly. I wondered how much more it would throb when I was inside of him.
“Please fuck me,” Eric muttered.
“What was that?” I teased, curling my finger inside him and making him groan.
“Fuck me, Matheson,” Eric said loudly.
I grasped Eric’s hips and pulled him backwards so that he faced away from me and my cock was aligned with his hole.
“I’m the one giving orders here,” I purred, stroking his cock for a moment. He let out a whimper as my hand withdrew. “Now stretch your hole for me so I can put my cock in you.”
Eric grumbled and reached back to open himself up. It might have been embarrassing for him, but the action was so fucking erotic I almost came on the spot. Even Colton and Ramsay’s breathing had noticeably sped up. The lube inside Eric’s hole trickled out and landed on my cock, making me shiver with anticipation.
Eric hovered over my cock, waiting for me to make the first move. I held his asscheek in one hand and guided the tip of my dick into his entrance with the other. My head slowly split him open again and Eric moaned, giving up all sense of shame. He wanted this so badly--and I wanted it just as fiercely.
