“Was that a goodwowor a bad one?” Ethan asked in a husky, needy voice as he pushed a little deeper.
I wet my lips, my breathing harsh and ragged. “I don’t know. Good?”
Meanwhile, Brodie was frantically trying to wiggle out of his jeans beneath me, and I instinctively grabbed a handful of his cock when it sprang free, stroking down his length. He moaned, hips bucking up from the bed, and Ethan took that as his cue to continue fingering my ass.
“Shit, Evie,” Brodie exclaimed, grasping both my tits in his hands as Ethan worked his finger in and out, teasing the opening each time. “Can I fuck your tits while he does that? I’ve been dreaming about these.”
Unable to form words, I nodded feverishly, my head swirling. Again, ticking another thing off my list of firsts as Brodie slithered up the bed enough that his cock perfectly aligned between my breasts.
“That’s it, Lilith, just relax,” Ethan murmured, grabbing the bottle of lube again and squirting more onto my ass. “We’ll make you feel so good.” Then he shoved what felt like his whole cock right into my slippery but still-clenched hole.
I cried out, even as Brodie gripped my tits around his cock, and Ethan whispered soothing words of encouragement for me to relax my muscles.
“I don’t know if I can take you both,” I moaned a minutelater. I’d finally unclenched my jaw and it didn’thurtbut it was uncomfortable as hell and he felt massive in my ass. I definitely couldn’t take anything in my pussy at the same time. “You’re so fucking big, Ethan.”
He paused. Then laughed. “Oh, baby girl. That’s still just my fingers, see?” He moved them in a scissor motion, stretching me in the strangest of ways. “My cock is bigger than that.”
What?!
Brodie laughed as well, thrusting between my tits until the tip of his cock smacked my chin. “Can you suck the tip, Evie?” I did as he asked, his precum coating my tongue as Ethan moved his fingers a little more, and I rocked back against him.
“Want me to stop?” Ethan asked even as he delved deeper. “If it’s too much?—”
“No!” I exclaimed as Brodie’s tip slipped out of my mouth. “No, keep going. I want to try.”
That was definitely the margaritas talking. Brodie gasped, then grabbed his own dick to stop himself titty-fucking me. “Sounds like you need a better distraction,” he murmured. “Something to help you enjoy the process.”
Before I could ask what he was thinking, the two of them had maneuvered us into a new position with my legs straddling Brodie’s face and my hands clutching the headboard for dear life as he ate my pussy again.
“So much better,” Ethan groaned with approval, working his fingers faster. “Fuck, I’m about to come in my pants I’m so horny right now. Eve, can I try?—?”
“Yes!” I gasped, already halfway delirious with what Brodie was doing between my legs. “Yes, fuck me…” I moaned, lost to the euphoria until something a whole hell of a lot bigger than two fingers pressed against my back door.
“Fuck, Lilith, you’re tense.” Ethan sounded somewhat frustrated.
I shook my head frantically. “It won’t fit, Ethan. It just won’t?—”
He cursed, then looped an arm around my waist, lifting me clean off Brodie and slamming me into the mattress. A split second later saw him buried balls deep in my pussy and I screamed with my instant orgasm.
“Holy shit,” he moaned, pumping hard and fast, sweat dripping down his chest as he chased his own release. “Fucking hell, you get me so horny, Eve. Christ, you’re gorgeous. This pussy is like fucking heaven.”
“Greedy,” Brodie protested, giving Ethan a shove. “Let me try.”
Ethan held me tight, rolling us even as my orgasm waned. I knew I was good for another one. These two had proven that already, so I was more than happy to keep going. In fact, that climax had loosened up all my muscles in a way that, when Brodie grabbed a handful of lube and slicked it down his shaft, I didn’t freak out. Hell, I just wiggled my ass with invitation.
“Shit yeah.” He smirked, then positioned himself behind me. “Ass up, Evie babe.”
I moaned, my pussy stuffed full of Ethan’s dick already. “Yes, Brodie, I want you to—” He started to push into my asshole and I yelped. “Nope! No. Too big. Too much. This isn’t going to work. Not both together. There’s no space.”
Ethan threaded his fingers into my hair, pulling my face down to kiss for the longest moment while Brodie swapped his huge cock for a finger instead. Finger, I could handle.
“You’re perfect, Eve,” Ethan whispered as his hips started to rock more forcefully, fucking me from below. “We’ll work up to it. Lots of practice.” Then he moaned as he came with a hard jerk, filling my cunt with his cum, triggering another mini-orgasm for me.
“I like the sound of practice,” Brodie agreed while my limbstrembled. “How’s this?” He added a second finger, fucking my ass with his hand like Ethan had just done.
I swallowed hard, my mouth dry and my head swimming with the aftershocks of climaxing. “It’s okay. I mean…it’s good. I’m good with this now.”
“Practice,” Ethan said again, kissing my shoulder as he slipped out of my pussy. “Try now, Brodes.”
