I smiled at her eagerness and watched as her nervous hands wrapped around my shaft, stroking me. Fuck, my sister was beautiful. I knew it was a sin to look at her like this, to feel perverse joy as she opened her mouth and her pink tongue swirled around the tip of my cock.
“Is this how I do it, Father? Is this how your little sister should take your large dick in her mouth? Please, Father, I don’t know what I’m doing.”
I couldn’t help smiling at the lies that slipped so easily from her lips. My little sister knew exactly what she was doing. I’d seen her at night in her room, touching that wet, warm cunt of hers.
I’d heard the way she panted and called my name as her hips rose off the bed like an offering to the heavens. I’d heard the filthy words she gasped when she came.
“That’s it, big brother. Fuck your slutty little sister. Please use me. Use your pathetic little whore.”
I knew exactly what Lyla craved. I’d denied my own yearning for her, chastised myself for years, but no more. Tonight I’d show my little sister exactly how much I wanted her too.
“I’m going to cast out the devil, Lyla, and it will require some unpleasant words. I might even hurt you with my actions. Please know that I don’t mean to. It’s the devil in me that needs casting out.”
“It’s okay,” Lyla said as my cock slipped from her mouth. “Do what you need to. I understand.” She smiled and winked.
My fingers tangled in her long blonde hair and I thrust my hips forward, lodging my cock deep in her mouth. “That’s a good girl. Show your big brother how much you want to suck his dick. This is what you wanted, isn’t it, sister? You’re awfully good at this. Were you lying when you pretended to be naive, Lyla? Your pretty little mouth is calling you a liar. Look at you… eager to suck your big brother’s cock.” I pulled out and yanked her head back. “Eyes on me, sis. Tell me how long have you wanted to suck my cock?”
Spit glistened at the corners of her mouth as she gazed up at me. “Since I was nineteen. I came home from college and saw you in the shower. You were hard, one hand braced against the wall, the other working your dick. You looked so hot as the water cascaded over your body, and your cock… it was so big and beautiful. I would have dropped to my knees right then and begged you to fuck my mouth.”
“That’s four years, Lyla. Well, baby sister, tonight I’m going to give you every dirty thing you’ve been dreaming about.”
Without warning I slammed back into her mouth until she gagged. Fuck, it felt perfect. I knew it was wrong, but I didn’t care. Nothing in my life had ever felt as right as my little sister choking on my dick.
She looked so innocent gazing up at me while she serviced my cock, but she was anything but. She’d known exactly what she was doing when she walked into the confessional. She wanted to break me, to force me to abandon my vows and surrender to the lust she’d kindled inside me.
She’d gotten exactly what she wanted. My damnation.
“Fuck,” I bellowed as I fucked her mouth with abandon. It was as if I were searching for light in the hell of lust she’d plunged me into. I hated myself for being so weak, but I also wondered why the Lord would test me in a way He knew I would fail. “Have you ever fucked another man, little sister?”
Lyla batted her long dark lashes and shook her head no, my cock still buried between her lips.
My balls tightened. I knew my release was close. But I didn’t want to finish in her mouth. What I craved was far more sinister. I wanted to tear through the last veil of her purity. I wanted to claim the one thing she could give only once.
Reluctantly I pulled out of her mouth, grabbed her hair, and yanked her to her feet. “We both need to repent. The Lord commands that I take what’s rightfully mine. I’m going to take this dirty pussy of yours. I’m going to impale you on my cock and fuck you until you can’t breathe. Do you hear me, sister? I’m going to own you. Once this is done, you’re mine and I’m yours. A union in the house of God, under His watchful eye.”
“Yes,” she panted. “Take me. Take your little sister. Make her yours. I’ve been such a bad girl and I need you to rectify my sins. Please.”
My hands fisted in her hair and I forced her to arch back as I lined my cock up with her warmth and thrust inside. I wasn’t gentle. I wanted to claim her. Own her body the way she already owned my soul.
At that moment I knew my only virtue would be her. To possess her, to love her, and to worship her. My vows were forsaken. The devil had won, and he wore the face of my little sister. “You are mine.”
“Yours,” she gasped.
“I feel your pussy tightening around me, sis. Are you going to come all over your big brother’s cock?”
“Yes. Fuck. Yes. God help me, I am.”
“God can’t help you. God can’t help either of us. The only thing that’s going to help is this.”
I grunted as I pounded into her, then moved my hand to her mouth and forced her lips apart. “Open. Get these fingers nice and wet for me. I’m going to finger that tight little asshole of yours, and when it’s ready I’m going to shove my cock deep inside. I’m going to claim every fucking hole. From this day forward you’re my little slut and you’ll do whatever I want, whenever I want. Do you hear me?”
“Yes,” Lyla said right before she wrapped her lips around my fingers.
Chapter
Four
LYLA
