"You'd have a tail," Thane added softly, his golden-brown eyes searching my face. "Like us. You could shift it to legs the way we do, visit land if you needed to. But..." He hesitated, something vulnerable crossing his features. "You'd feel what we feel. The wrongness of air in your lungs. The discomfort of being away from the water too long. Land would never feel like home again."
"You'd be a siren," Kaelan said, his voice rough and serious. "Forever. Not human anymore. You could technically walk among them for short periods, the way we do. You'd never belong to that world again." His dark eyes held mine, fierce and afraid all at once. "You'd belong to the sea. To us."
I stared at him. At all of them. Not human anymore. Belonging to the sea. Forever changed. The words should have terrified me. Should have sent me scrambling for the surface, for the world I knew, for the life I'd been clinging to for so long.
But what life? What world?
A world where I was property. Where my own father had sold me. Where every alpha I met looked at me and saw gold instead of a person. Where I'd spent eight months running, hiding, surviving—but never, never living.
"What would I be giving up?" I asked, my voice steady, my eyes moving from face to face. "Really. Tell me what I'd be losing."
Silence. Heavy, weighted silence.
"Your humanity," Vale said finally, his voice soft with something like grief, his silver eyes searching my face. "You'd still be you—still think, still feel, still love. It’s your body that would be different. You'd look at humans and know you weren't one of them anymore."
"Humans have never treated me like one of them," I said quietly, remembering the way alphas looked at me, the way my father had counted coins while discussing my price. "They treated me like property. Like livestock. Being human never protected me from anything."
"The sun," Thane offered, his voice small, his golden-brown eyes glistening with unshed tears. "You could still surface, still feel it on your skin. But it wouldn't call to you the same way. The water would always pull you back."
"I've spent eight months hiding from the sun," I said, remembering endless days in cargo holds and below decks and dark corners where no one would look twice at a runaway omega. "It was never warm. It was just another thing that could expose me."
"Land," Kaelan said, his voice rough, his dark eyes pained. "You could still walk on it, the way we do. But it would feel wrong. Uncomfortable. You'd always be counting the minutes until you could return to the water."
I thought about that one. Really thought.
"The earth was never solid for me," I said finally, the words coming out slow and certain. "I was always running. Always moving. Always looking over my shoulder, waiting for the ground to open up and swallow me whole." I reached up,touching his face, feeling the sharp lines of his jaw. "This is the first time I've ever felt like I had somewhere to stand."
"You'd be giving up the option of going back," Riven said, his voice low and serious, his golden eyes burning into mine. "Even if you could walk among humans for a few hours, you'd never be able to live as one again. Never blend in. Never pretend to be something you're not." Something flickered in his expression—understanding, maybe. Recognition. "The human world would be closed to you forever."
"Good," I said, and the word came out fierce, surprising even me. "I don't want to go back. I don't want to blend in. I don't want to pretend." I looked at each of them in turn, Kaelan with his dark, ancient eyes; Riven with his scars and his desperate hunger; Vale with his silver beauty and his devastating voice; Thane with his golden warmth and his tender heart. "I want to be what I really am. I want to belong somewhere. I want you."
Kaelan made a sound, low and broken and desperate, and pulled me against him, his arms wrapping around me so tight it almost hurt.
"You're sure," he said against my hair, his voice cracking on the words, his body trembling with the effort of holding himself together. "Lily, you have to be sure. This is permanent. There's no going back. Once you change?—"
"I've never been more sure of anything in my life," I interrupted, pulling back to look at him, to look at all of them. "I'm giving up a world that never wanted me. A life that was never really mine. I'm giving up running and hiding and being afraid." I took a deep breath, feeling the strange sensation of air filling my lungs in this pocket of atmosphere they'd created just for me. "And I'm getting you. All of you. A pack. A home. A place where I belong."
"You belong with us," Thane said fiercely, tears streaming down his face now, his arms tightening around my waist frombehind. "You've always belonged with us. From the very first moment."
"Then let me belong with you forever," I said simply, letting the truth of it settle in my chest. "Let me become one of you." The sound that escaped Riven wasn't human. It was raw and broken and desperate, a thousand years of loneliness cracking open all at once. He crashed into me, his arms joining Thane's around my waist, his face buried in my neck, his whole body shaking with silent sobs.
Vale pressed close from the other side, his hand stroking through my hair, his tears falling freely, his voice murmuring words I couldn't quite make out but understood anyway. Kaelan—steady, ancient, unbreakable Kaelan—cupped my face in his hands and looked at me like I was the most precious thing he'd ever seen.
"Tomorrow," he said, his voice rough with emotion, his dark eyes swimming with tears he refused to let fall. "We'll do it tomorrow. Tonight..." He pressed his forehead to mine, breathing me in. "Tonight, you're ours just as you are. Human and all."
"Tomorrow," I agreed, feeling the word settle into my bones like a promise. "Tomorrow, I become one of you."
"Tomorrow," Riven echoed against my neck, his voice muffled but fierce.
"Tomorrow," Vale whispered, his lips brushing my temple.
"Tomorrow," Thane sobbed, his arms squeezing me tight enough to bruise. We stayed like that for a long time—tangled together on the stone ledge of their den, surrounded by treasures and soft furs and the soft glow of bioluminescent light filtering up from the water below, breathing each other in. I could feel their heartbeats against my skin, faster than human hearts, stronger, pulsing with ancient power. Could smell their scentssurrounding me, layering over my own, marking me as theirs even without conscious effort.
My pack.
My home.
My future.
