I no longer have the willpower to fight her. Fear that I will hurt her still pulses inside me, but I’m not sure there is any way around it. I wish I would have researched this more. I should have been studying how to make the first time good for your partner instead of my playbooks.
Jenny must see the conflict in my eyes because she begins soothing me the minute my cock nudges at her entrance and I hesitate. “I know it might hurt, but I want it. I want you inside me. Because after the pain, I know there will be bliss.”
Nodding, I look down between us as I guide the head of my cock past her entrance. She’s so fucking tight and wet I think I might lose my mind. I’m not going to last, that much is crystal clear. “Fuck, I’m afraid this is going to be over so fast, Jenny. I’m not even sure you’ll have time to get to the bliss.”
“After you come, stay in me. Don’t leave me.” Jenny grips my ass and pulls me another inch inside her until I feel the tight ring of her virginity.
Trying everything I can think of to lessen the pain, I latch on to her nipple, sucking and biting at it the way I discovered she loves. I release the base of my cock and press my thumb to her clit, massaging it in circles. All my efforts seem to work. Jenny rocks her hips against me in a silent plea to slide deeper. And I do. All at once, I thrust hard to the hilt, bite down on her puckered nipple, and pinch her clit. Jenny wraps her arms around my shoulders, panting and moaning my name directly into my ear.
“Spencer, I’m so full. I feel you everywhere. Don’t move yet. I just want to feel you.” I do as she asks, staying perfectly still inside her.
My orgasm is begging to be released inside her. I clamp down on it, trying with everything I have not to give in to the incessant need to let go. But it’s no use. Without meaning to, my hips thrust tighter against her pussy, pushing me impossibly deeper, until I reach the end of her. That one slight movement sets me off. Something inside me snaps, and I’m pulling out and thrusting into her over and over again as I dump every bit of my cum into her welcoming pussy.
Through it, the knowledge that there is no protection between us ramps up my arousal, making me spurt longer and harder than I thought possible. I could give her a baby right now. Our very first time, officially no longer virgins, and I could make her a mom. Something about that line of thought brings the caveman back out.
Despite having just come, my cock doesn’t soften even a little bit. “Feel me filling up your tight virgin cunt, Jenny?”
“Fuck yes, I feel it inside me. Dripping down my ass and thighs too. It is so hot, Spencer.” She arches her neck, bringing our lips together in a mind-melting kiss.
I don’t slow my thrusts during the kiss. The combination of my cum and her slick arousal eases the way for me to tunnel my cock in and out of her tight channel at a brutal pace. “I’m going to keep fucking you until that little pussy milks every drop of my seed from my cock. And that seed with take root inside you. A little piece of me is going to join with a piece of you and be together forever in our baby.”
“Yessss. Why does that make me hot?” She whines against my ear as another orgasm rockets through her body, and she clamps down on my dick. It’s like a chain reaction. Her orgasm triggers mine, and before I know what’s happening, I’m emptying my balls inside her once more. At this point, they almost ache from the two quick orgasms.
And I still keep going.
