Evie moans and grips my neck tighter, panting with the effort to go slowly. I desperately want to praise her, tell her she's a good girl, but Cormac and I agreed I needed to keep quiet, so I try to show her with a kiss to her neck.
"Three. Two."
Cormac's eyes are glued to Evie's ass, as he fumbles with a bottle of lube. He finally pops it open, and then he slicks his thumb with the slippery liquid. "One."
Evie drops the rest of the way down, rolling her hips as she rides Cormac's cock frantically.
"Oh, yes. Oh, yes!" she yells, giving into the pleasure as she fucks Cormac with abandon.
I've never seen anything so sexy in my life. She runs a hand along her breast. I don't want to mess up her rhythm, so I massage her perfect tits, pinching her nipples as she moans out her appreciation for us.
All of a sudden, she freezes and moans.
"Fuuuuccckkkkk."
I look behind her, and Cormac has his thumb in her tight little back hole. He moves it in and out as he pumps up into her pussy with his cock, alternating thrusts into both her holes.
I slide in front of Evie, placing my hands behind my back to hold myself upright, and Cormac pushes her forward gently. "Evie, baby. Fill your mouth."
She reaches for me, searching eagerly for my cock and falls to it like a magnet.
We both moan as her lips wrap around the tip. She swirls her tongue, and my fingers are in her hair as she drools with the effort to take me. Suddenly, she swallows and takes me deep, milking my cock with her throat, and I throw my head back with a loud moan.
"Fuck, Evie," I grit out, and then still, realizing I've just given myself away. Cormac freezes too, his eyes on mine as we wait to see if she noticed.
Evie comes off my cock with a loud pop, panting as she tries to catch her breath.
"Did you like that, Nash, baby?"
5
Cormac
Iquickly untie the blindfold, and Nash's eyes darken as our girl gets a look at him for the first time tonight. He stares at her with a mixture of worry and infatuation, his eyes flitting across her face as he waits for her reaction.
But Evie just rolls her hips, moaning as she grips my cock with her tight core. She leans forward and wraps her mouth back around Nash's cock. Her head bobs up and down like it's back to business.
I've had a plan for months to make this happen. Longer if I'm being honest, and I've suspected she is more than on board. But this proves it to me. She’s always been ours.
I glance at Nash, his eyes locked on Evie as she deep throats his cock like a fucking champion. He's huge and thick, which can be a lot for some women. Not Evie.
"You're going to ride Nash, baby,” I say, and she moans. “He wants to look at you when you fuck him." Nash nods in affirmation, and Evie comes off of his cock with sloppy suction. She quickly scrambles onto his lap and wraps her arms around his neck. They both look down as he holds his cock in place for her.
"You are such a big boy," Evie breathes out, and Nash moans from her words. One of his kinks is praise, whereas mine is a bit of degradation. I love watching her get pleasure from another cock, and if she insults mine a little in the process, that will have me rock hard. But Nash loves being told he’s huge and perfect.
Evie puts her forehead to his as she slides onto his cock, and they share a moment that makes my heart beat faster with excitement.
I wasn't wrong about her. About us.
Evie moans, rocking on Nash as she chases her pleasure. I motion for Nash to lay down all the way, and then I push her forward. I spread her cheeks wide for me and then feast on her perfect asshole. She moans when Nash holds her to his chest, forcing her to take what I'm giving her.
"Oh fuck, yes. Oh, please, Cormac. Fuck me," Evie begs, and I finally pull myself away. I squirt the lube directly on her ass, running my hard cock through it. Nash still holds her to his chest, and she moans, kissing his chest and sucking on his nipple until he can't help but thrust up into her.
"Don't move. Let me take this slowly," I warn, pushing the tip of my cock past the tight ring of muscle and then letting out a feral growl as she tightens around me and moans.
"Oh fuck, baby. Do that again," Nash grits out, and Evie tightens around us again, making us all groan.
"Fuck me, Cormac. I can take it," Evie pants, nodding as I push inside and pull out slowly. I know she can. I’ve been preparing her for this for months. She moans loudly when I thrust in, and I continue with a slow rhythm as Nash starts up again as well.
