“No?” he said as he ran a finger over her puckered hole, making her shiver. “You think it’s okay to lie to your Daddy and Papa?”
“No,” she cried. “But I was overwrought! I thought I’d killed Rudolph.”
He had to grin. She could be so dramatic sometimes. Seemed they’d gone from her hitting Rudolph to killing him.
“Cherry, it was a deer and the pompom from your hat. You didn’t hit the animal, and it wasn’t Rudolph.”
“I know that now,” she grumbled.
“I don’t think you can use that as an excuse for lying,” he said firmly as he pushed the tip of one finger inside her. There was some resistance and he waited for her to relax before he pushed the finger in further.
A small groan escaped from them both. Fuck, it was hot watching his finger disappear into her asshole.
“I really think I should get some leniency,” she told him as Jenner came out of the bathroom with the two plugs.
“Here we are, one hot and one cold,” he said.
“You are getting some leniency,” Tobias said as he pushed a second finger inside her while Jenner lubed up the warm plug. He then handed it to Tobias who drew his fingers out of her ass. “You’re not getting a spanking on top of your plugging.”
Immy grumbled as he started to push the plug into her bottom.
“Oh God. That is so firm and warm,” she said. “Cupcakes!”
“Too much?” Jenner asked as he kneeled next to her on the bed.
“Nooo,” she groaned.
“You can let go of your butt cheeks now,” Tobias said. “The plug is fully inside you. I’m going to clean my hands, then help you kneel up so Jenner can fuck you with the cold candy cane.”
Dear Lord.
Those weren’t words she’d ever thought that someone would say to her.
But here she was with one warm candy cane plug inside her and other cool one about to enter her pussy.
“Maybe cool it down again,” Jenner said.
“Will do.” Tobias disappeared and she breathed in heavily as she heard the water run.
“You’re doing so well, baby girl,” Jenner praised her as he pushed her hair off her face. “Daddy’s good girl.”
Was she?
“Have I been a good girl?” she asked, turning her face toward him.
“The best,” he told her, kissing her lightly.
“I thought I was going to have to do some magic to put Rudolph together again.”
Jenner just smiled.
“Here you are,” Tobias said before he drew her up so she was kneeling with her legs wide. The plug in her ass shifted and she groaned in arousal.
This was too much.
Immy just hoped that she was going to get to come.
Jenner kneeled in front of her. “Let’s just make sure that you’re nice and wet.”
