“Exactly. Jonathan was able to get the web browser off the ground long before Ian could raise the funds.”
“And Jonathan’s company went on to become a huge success.”
“It did. Ian was devastated. He’d been betrayed by someone he trusted. He slipped into depression.”
Tess’s heartache was a palpable thing. Leah could feel it against her skin. “His father and I persuaded him to sue Jonathan,” Tess continued, “and he improved somewhat during that process. He had hope that right would prevail ... that justice would win.”
“I know that the suit didn’t go his way.”
“I wish, very dearly, that it had. Jonathan was able to afford excellent lawyers. So, no. The case didn’t go Ian’s way. Afterward, we tried and tried to reach him, to help him. But we couldn’t get through. He committed suicide a year later.”
“I’m very sorry.”
Tess’s gaze met hers. “Unless you’ve lost a child, you can’t imagine the grief. I loved Ian with every fiber of my being. His death is not something I’ve ever recovered from, nor ever will. I went on because I had another child, family members, work responsibilities. But Idid notget over it. Half my heart belonged to Ian. And still does.”
“I understand.”
“My marriage to Malcolm fell apart. We divorced. Suddenly I was without one of my sons, without my husband. I was struggling with depression myself when one day, at work, I learned that Jonathan Brookside’s wife was giving birth at my hospital. Magnolia Avenue was located near Atlanta’s best neighborhoods, of course. Some of the most well-respected obstetricians in the city delivered babies there.”
“Did you see Jonathan that day?”
She shook her head. “I was working in the nursery when both you and the Montgomery baby arrived for treatment and observation. After the pediatrician finished and said that you were both well enough to be returned to your mothers, I found myself alone with the two of you.”
“Jonathan had taken your baby. And now you had the chance to take his.”
“Yes. That was the precise thought that entered my head.”
“You wanted to punish Jonathan.”
“It’s true. I wanted retribution for what he’d done to Ian. He’d gotten off scot-free, you see. He’d never paid any price at all for ruining my son’s life ... and mine.” She turned her glass in a circle, then set her hands in her lap. “The things I felt and did in that moment are difficult, even for me, to comprehend. I’d never broken a rule in my life. But neither had Ian, and look where that got him.”
Quiet wafted between them, and Leah registered the distant sound of Rudy’s TV show, of a bird’s song.
“I switched you with the Montgomery baby, which took some doing, as far as your ID bands and records went. When Tracyentered the nursery, I asked her to take you back to your mothers. And off you went.”
“And that was that.”
“I was certain I’d get caught. For days. Weeks. But no one was the wiser.”
“How did the Bonnie O’Reilly who worked at Magnolia Avenue become Tess Coventry?”
“I was born Bonnie Theresa Byrne. My mother gave me the middle name Theresa in honor of her sister, then called me what she’d always called her sister: Tess ... which is short for Theresa. Everyone in my family called me Tess, but at school and around town, I went by Bonnie. When I married Malcolm, I became Bonnie O’Reilly. Then, years afer my divorce, I met Rudy. When he found out that my family called me Tess, he started calling me Tess, too. Then I married him and my last name changed to Coventry.”
“But even if you were Tess to Rudy and your family, shouldn’t you have been Bonnie Coventry to everyone else?”
“Had I not switched two babies, I would have been. In an effort to at least partially cover my tracks, ease my paranoia, and make things difficult for anyone searching for Bonnie O’Reilly, I convinced Rudy to move outside of Atlanta. I took a job at a new hospital and introduced myself to everyone there as Tess. Over time, I became Tess to all.” Politely, she moved a cookie onto her napkin. “May I ask how you found me?”
Leah gave Tess the SparkNotes version of her search.
“Ah.”
“Who else knows that you switched Sophie and me?” Leah asked.
“Just you, me, and God. The secret of what I did has been a companion invisible to everyone except me. Until now.”
“I’m inferring that our meeting at the middle school in Gainesville was not a coincidence.”
“No, it wasn’t. I often worried that what I’d done had impacted you and Sophie negatively. I looked for information on the two of you but never could find anything until I came upon an article featuring you as the brightest of the students who were attendingClemmons. I was delighted, truly, to discover that you were a math prodigy, to know that you’d flourished.”
