“Yes. But not a lot. And he was small.”
James reaches over and pulls open our nightstand drawer. “Did you like it?”
“Yes.” She sounds breathless, and she is questing more now, trying to reach between us and shift me so she can ride my cock.
I’m not inside her yet and the hint of her heat has me gritting my teeth. I want to pound into her with everything I’ve got, but not yet. I want to torture us both while James gets her ready to take his cock up her ass.
“Easy,” I tell her, holding her hips. “Let James get you ready to take both of us.”
“What did you like about it?” James asks her, squeezing lube onto his fingers and sliding his hand between her cheeks.
She shudders a little, which lets me know he’s put a finger inside her.
“It just felt…good, in a surprising way. He couldn’t really…fill my pussy, but he could my ass. He would put a vibrator inside me and fuck me from behind that way. It was…” she sucks in her breath. “Fun.Oh, God, James.”
I’m not jealous of the mystery man from her past with the small dick. If anything, I’m grateful he prepped her for us because, undoubtedly, James has more to offer than this past lover did. We need her to have been stretched at least a little.
“You like that, baby?” he asks her.
I can see his arm moving as he pumps his fingers in and out of her.
She’s wiggling against me.
“You ready for my cock?” I ask.
She nods so eagerly I laugh softly.
Gripping her hips, I lift her slightly and seat her on me. She gives a soft shuddery moan.
My eyes briefly fall shut. Jesus, she’s perfect. “Sweet Caroline. You have such a hot, tight pussy. The way you grip my cock…”
“Yes,” she breathes. “I love you inside me, Cas. I feel so full.”
“You’re about to be filled even more.” James runs his hands down over the back of her hair and pushes her forward. “Lean onto Cas.”
She obediently puts her palms down on either side of my head and presses her chest against mine. I lift my hips to start to fuck her, slowly, leisurely, while reaching around and pulling her cheeks apart for James.
“Let me just test you, Caro,” he says, moving in behind her. “Tell me if it’s too much.”
She’s rocking onto me, eyes drifting closed. She jerks just a little and pauses when he pushes into her. Her mouth drops open on a soft sigh of wonderment.
“Okay?”
She nods. “Yes. So good.”
“Open your eyes,” I tell her, gripping her hips tightly. I’m holding back from pounding her the way I want to, but I’m still enjoying every single second. I want to watch her as my husband takes her ass.
When her eyes pop open, they’re glassy. She’s deep into her body, the pleasure, the sensation of being taken by two men at the same time. James and I have an alternating rhythm going, steady, but easy, neither of us taking her deeply.
“What do you think?” I ask. “How do you like being fucked by two men?”
“I think I have a new hobby.”
That makes me laugh softly. “I think she needs more, James.”
I can see how tense her arms are, how his teeth are gritted, and the vein in his neck is bulging. “Gladly,” he responds.
Caroline tenses. “Relax, sweetheart.” I run my finger over her lip, easing it into her mouth. “Suck on this.”
